STATE OF FLORIDA

DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS

DR. PAUL JOSEPH RUCINSKI, )

)

Petitioner, )

)

vs. ) CASE NO. 87-1593

) STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT ) OF PROFESSIONAL REGULATION, ) BOARD OF MEDICINE, )

)

Respondent. )

)

RECOMMENDED ORDER

On July 27, 1987, a formal hearing was held in this cause. The authority for the conduct of the hearing was Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes. This recommended order is being entered following the receipt and review of proposed recommended orders offered by the parties. In addition, the transcript of proceedings has been examined. The fact proposals suggested by the parties have been incorporated to some extent in the fact finding offered through the recommended order. Otherwise, the proposed facts are distinguished in an appendix to the recommended order.

APPEARANCES

FOR PETITIONER: Frank M. Gafford, Esquire

Post Office Box 1789

34 North Marion Street

Lake City, Florida 32056-1789

FOR RESPONDENT: Patricia V. Russo, Esquire

M. Catherine Lannon, Esquire Assistant Attorneys General Department of Legal Affairs Room 1601, The Capitol Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050

ISSUES

The issues presented concern the question of whether Dr. Paul Joseph Rucinski (Petitioner) has completed the prerequisites for standing the license examination of the State of Florida, Department of Professional Regulation, Board of Medicine (Respondent). This examination is known as the FLEX examination. In particular, Petitioner has been denied the opportunity to take this examination based upon the perception held by the Respondent that Petitioner did not complete core clerkship training in internal medicine, one of the prerequisites to undergo the examination session.

FINDINGS OF FACT

1. Petitioner attended medical school at Ross University in the British West Indies and received his medical degree. Consequently, for purposes of license examination in Florida, Dr. Rucinski is considered to be a foreign medical graduate.

   
   

2. Part of the medical training in his undergraduate course work was received in the United States. This education was in association with completion of clerkships necessary to obtain his medical degree.

   
   

3. An organization known as the Jacksonville Health Education Program, constituted of certain hospitals in the city of Jacksonville, Florida, was providing clerkship training for medical students during the time within which Petitioner received his clerkship training. The Jacksonville Health Education Program (JHEP) was affiliated with the University of Florida School of Medicine and as such was part of that institution's educational program. In this connection, Petitioner was referred to JHEP as an organization which could arrange for his clinical clerkship training.

   
   

4. As described in Petitioner's Exhibit 4 admitted into evidence, Petitioner received clerkship training in psychiatry, ob/gyn, surgery, pediatrics, family practice, dermatology, anesthesiology, general surgery, emergency room medicine and critical care, all through JHEP. Respondent takes no issue with the sufficiency of that training to establish credentials for license examination in Florida. This point of view is held because Respondent is convinced that the institutions within which the training in the various specialties was conducted were allopathic institutions.

   
   

5. The only contention in this cause arises based upon the Respondent's belief that the clerkship training which Petitioner received in internal medicine was not given in an institution associated with JHEP and did not have allopathic emphasis. Instead, the focus of the training in internal medicine was alleged by the Respondent to be osteopathic. This speaks to core clerkship training the Petitioner received in internal medicine at Jacksonville General Hospital, Jacksonville, Florida, now known as Jacksonville Medical Center.

   
   

6. The period of time within which the training was received was November 5, 1982, to January 27, 1983, and again on April 11, 1983, to June 17, 1983. The clerkship in internal medicine was supervised by Dr. Glenn J. Gerber, an osteopathic physician. According to Dr. Gerber, Petitioner successfully completed his core clerkship training in internal medicine as evidenced by the evaluation forms set forth in Petitioner's composite Exhibit 7 admitted into evidence. Although Dr. Gerber is not licensed pursuant to Chapter 458, Florida Statutes, to practice allopathic medicine, he was board certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine in the field of internal medicine effective 1978. This board is a board pertaining to allopathic medicine. Moreover, Dr.

   Gerber's unrefuted testimony establishes that training in internal medicine for allopathic medical students versus osteopathic medical students does not differ. To his understanding, textbooks do not exist which deal with osteopathic internal medicine separate and apart from allopathic internal medicine. During the time that Dr. Gerber taught at the Jacksonville General Hospital, to include the time of instruction pertaining to Petitioner, other students who sought medical degrees in allopathic medicine were involved in training which he conducted. Dr. Gerber served as the director of clinical education for the Jacksonville General Hospital during the period 1981 through 1984.

7. The nature of the internal medicine training which Petitioner received through Jacksonville General Hospital was under the auspices of an internal medicine service for students as well as residents. The daily functions of the core internal medicine training included daily rounds where patients were met who had been admitted the night before and involvement with patients who were being managed on an ongoing basis. This training included frequent pathology rounds, cardiology rounds almost daily and radiology rounds daily. Typically, different topics were considered which had been assigned the night before. An example would be miocardial infraction. Discussions were entered into on current management and therapy.

   
   

8. On October 18, 1976, Jacksonville General Hospital was informed by letter that it had been accepted as a member of the JHEP Consortium. This correspondence was from D. J. Lanahan, president of the JHEP Board of Trustees and appears on the stationery of J. Hillis Miller Health Center, College of Medicine, University of Florida, Jacksonville Division. A copy of the letter is found as Petitioner's Exhibit 10 admitted into evidence. This correspondence does not set forth a circumstance whereby Jacksonville General Hospital is received as a member for purposes of offering core clerkship training in allopathic medicine, nor does it establish a contrary position. On the other hand, Lois Gray, director of medical legal affairs at Jacksonville Medical Center, offered unrefuted testimony that Dr. Gerber held a faculty appointment with JHEP. Petitioner's Exhibit 11 admitted into evidence, which describes the nature of JHEP's affiliation with the University of Florida, J. Hillis Miller Health Center, speaks to the concept of undergraduate medical education but it is silent on the question of Jacksonville General Hospital's involvement in the education of undergraduate medical students and their clinical clerkship training. Respondent's Exhibit 4 admitted into evidence concerns the fact that the Jacksonville General Hospital in the years 1982 and 1983 was associated with the American Osteopathic Association and provided internship programs and residency programs related to osteopathic medicine; however, this excerpt of the yearbook and directory of osteopathic physicians does not exclude the possibility of affiliation with the accrediting organization related to hospitals that provide allopathic care. In fact, Jacksonville General Hospital was recognized as an allopathic facility by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals in the relevant time frame.

   
   

9. Further, an excerpt of the 1982-83 directory of residency training programs accredited by the accreditation council of graduate medical education, a complimentary copy from the American Medical Association, was offered and received as Respondent's Exhibit 5 admitted into evidence. This document speaks to the provision of residency training by Jacksonville hospitals affiliated with JHEP. It does not include an indication that Jacksonville General Hospital was one of the institutions providing residency training in the Jacksonville, Florida, area in the relevant years. However, it does not speak to undergraduate medical training. Therefore, it does not establish the fact that Jacksonville General Hospital did not offer allopathic medical training in internal medicine to the Petitioner as part of core clerkship training.

   Finally, Respondent's attempt to introduce the remarks of Dr. Will Neal of the University of Florida, School of Medicine, does not serve to corroborate competent evidence offered by the Respondent on the subject of Jacksonville General Hospital's lack of affiliation with JHEP and failure to provide undergraduate medical training in allopathic medicine. His remarks are hearsay and stand alone and cannot be utilized in fact finding for reasons explained in the conclusions of law.

10. Jacksonville General Hospital, in 1982, had among its active staff, 40

    M.D.s and 31 D.O.s.

    
    

11. On the whole, Dr. Rucinski is found to have received appropriate allopathic medical training in his core clerkship in internal medicine.

    
    

12. Dr. Rucinski is currently undergoing training at the University of Wisconsin, affiliated hospitals program, St. Luke's Hospital, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. This is a hospital that has association with the American Medical Association. Dr. Rucinski is a resident in postgraduate year 3. Dr. Rucinski is interested in general medicine, family practice. As part of his postgraduate training, he has had extensive training in internal medicine which he has successfully responded to. He has not been able to discern differences in the underlying emphasis in the internal medicine training received as a resident in St. Luke's Hospital and that received at Jacksonville General Hospital.

    
    

13. Against this background, prior to August 15, 1986, Petitioner made timely application to take the FLEX examination to gain a license to practice medicine in the state of Florida. This examination was to be given December 2- 4, 1986.

    
    

14. On November 12, 1986, Dr. Rucinski was invited to appear before the Foreign Medical Graduate Committee of the Board of Medicine. A copy of that invitation may be found as part of Petitioner's Exhibit 6 admitted into evidence. In addition to the invitation, a second item within that exhibit describes the subjects upon which he could be interrogated and makes specific reference to items which could be submitted in furtherance of this session, but these items were not exclusive. This speaks to his passport and visa involved with time periods when he was out of the United States during his medical training. The second page indicated that the Petitioner should be prepared to provide documentation of his physical location for periods of medical education.

    
    

15. Petitioner made the appearance on November 21, 1986, and was examined by members of the Foreign Medical Graduate Committee, and it was determined to deny Petitioner's opportunity to stand the FLEX examination based upon the belief held by the committee members that his internal medicine clerkship was osteopathic training and unacceptable. Petitioner was made aware that the committee would recommend to the Board of Medicine that he not be allowed to take the FLEX examination. These remarks were offered at the time of Petitioner's appearance before the foreign medical graduate committee on November 21, 1986. On the next day, the Board of Medicine, in furtherance of the recommendation of the committee, declared Petitioner ineligible to stand examination.

    
    

16. On November 24, 1986, Petitioner was advised in writing of the decision of the Board of Medicine. A copy of that exhibit may be found as Petitioner's Exhibit 5 admitted into evidence, and it states that the request to stand examination is denied. It goes on to suggest that an order would be prepared which set forth the reasons for denial. The letter identifies the fact that the Petitioner could then request a hearing pursuant to Section 120.57, Florida Statutes, following receipt of the final order. That final order was entered on February 19, 1987, and may be found as part of Respondent's composite Exhibit 1 admitted into evidence. It indicates that the reason for denial is that the Petitioner had failed to complete allopathic medical education as described in Chapter 458, Florida Statutes, related to the inadequacy, as the Board of Medicine saw it, of Petitioner's core clerkship in internal medicine, in that the training was osteopathic in nature and not allopathic medical

    education. The Petitioner received a copy of the order of denial in late February 1987. Petitioner took issue with this point of view and petitioned for a formal Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes, hearing. That petition was received as filed before the Respondent on March 15, 1987.

    
    

17. The Division of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties to this action pursuant to Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes.

    
    

18. Respondent's Exhibit 4 is admitted into evidence.

    
    

19. The proffered testimony of Dr. Will Neal is not accepted as evidence which can lead to factual findings. This determination is made in accordance with Section 120.58, Florida Statutes. Although a reasonably prudent person might expect the individual who is associated with the University of Florida medical school, such as Dr. Neal, would have some understanding of those institutions which are part of the JHEP program, his remarks do not constitute an exception to the proposition that hearsay evidence is not competent evidence. Furthermore, his remarks do not serve to supplement, corroborate or explain otherwise competent evidence. Consequently, they cannot be relied upon in determining relevant facts in this inquiry.

    
    

20. In the deposition of Dr. Gerber wherein he attempts to explain the similarities between the core clerkship program in internal medicine at Jacksonville General Hospital and the residency program in internal medicine that he had some involvement with at St. Vincent's Hospital in Jacksonville, Florida, is not accepted, based upon the belief that it is irrelevant testimony.

    
    

21. Petitioner, who seeks licensure, has the burden to prove his entitlement to stand the FLEX examination. See Balino vs. Dept. of Health & Rehab. Serv., 348 So.2d 349 (Fla. 1st DCA 1977). To that end, Respondent has accepted his candidacy for licensure with the exception of the question of his training in internal medicine while a medical student. That training must have been allopathic medical education as envisioned by Section 458.331(3), Florida Statutes (Supp. 1986). On balance, Petitioner has carried the burden. He received training in an institution which he was led to believe had affiliation with JHEP, an accepted educational outreach from the University of Florida medical school. The institution where he received internal medicine training and core clerkship was one accredited by the accrediting agency for allopathic hospitals. The training was supervised by an osteopathic physician. Nonetheless, this physician and the Petitioner have established that the nature of training in internal medicine for allopaths and osteopaths at the student level is akin. Moreover, the expertise of Dr. Gerber in internal medicine had been recognized by the board certifying organization related to allopathic internal medicine practice. It is not unreasonable to expect that these credentials could be brought to bear in the training of Dr. Rucinski. Finally, although it does not speak directly to the question of his competence gained through undergraduate medical training at the point in time wherein he sought the opportunity to take the FLEX examination, Dr. Rucinski's successful performance in his residency program in an allopathic hospital in the subject area of internal medicine should allay any fears that he is not a fit candidate to stand examination at this point in time.

    
    

22. Respondent, in considering the fitness of the Petitioner to stand license examination in the December 1986 examination session did not act contrary to the purposes of Section 120.60, Florida Statutes.

Based upon a consideration of the facts found and conclusions of law reached, it is,

RECOMMENDED:

That a final order be entered which grants the Petitioner the opportunity to take the FLEX examination for licensure to practice medicine in the state of Florida in accordance with Section 458, Florida Statutes.

DONE AND ENTERED this 10th day of September, 1987, at Tallahassee, Florida.

CHARLES C. ADAMS, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building

2009 Apalachee Parkway

Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550

(904) 488-9675

Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 10th day of September, 1987.

APPENDIX TO RECOMMENDED ORDER IN CASE NO. 87-1593

Having considered the fact proposals of the parties, those proposals were accepted with the following exceptions:

Petitioner's facts

At paragraph 2, the reference to December 21, 1986, is corrected to November 21, 1986.

Paragraph 5 is subordinate to facts found.

Paragraph 6 is a recitation of a statutory provision. It is not fact finding.

Paragraphs 7 through 18 are subordinate to facts found. Paragraph 19 constitutes legal argument and not fact finding.

Respondent's facts

Paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 are subordinate to facts found.

Paragraph 4 is accurate, but it is also noted that Jacksonville General Hospital offered allopathic care as well.

Paragraphs 5 and 6 are subordinate to facts found. Paragraph 7 is contrary to facts found.

Paragraph 8 is subordinate to facts found.

COPIES FURNISHED:

Frank M. Gafford, Esquire Post Office Box 1789

34 North Marion Street

Lake City, Florida 32056-1789

Patricia V. Russo, Esquire

M. Catherine Lannon, Esquire Assistant Attorneys General Department of Legal Affairs Room 1601, The Capitol Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050

Dorothy Faircloth, Executive Director Board of Medicine

Department of Professional Regulation

130 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0750

Tom Gallagher, Secretary

Department of Professional Regulation

130 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0750

Docket for Case No: 87-001593

Orders for Case No: 87-001593