Findings Of Fact Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence produced at the hearing, the following relevant facts are found: At all times pertinent to this proceeding Respondent Larkins was licensed as an embalmer and funeral director by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, having been issued licensed numbers FE 2310, E 2310 and FD 2106. At all times pertinent to this proceeding the Respondent Anderson was licensed as a funeral director and embalmer by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, having been issued license numbers FE 2204, E 2204 and FD 2003. At all times pertinent to this proceeding Respondent Evans was licensed as an embalmer and funeral director by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, having been issued license numbers FE 790, E 790 and 672. At all times pertinent to this proceeding Respondent Stone was licensed as a funeral director and embalmer by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, having been issued license numbers FE 459, E 459 and 205. At all times pertinent to this proceeding Respondent Stone Funeral Home was licensed as a funeral establishment by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, having been issued license number FH 214. The corporate officers of said establishment are Fannie B. Stone, President; Rosalyn Gordon, Secretary- Treasurer; and Raymond S. Gordon, Vice-President. Raymond S. Gordon's address is the same as the Respondent funeral establishment, 2401 East Columbus Drive, Tampa, Florida. Neither Raymond S. Gordon nor Rosalyn Gordon have ever been licensed as a funeral director, embalmer, funeral director intern or embalmer intern by the Florida Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers. James Williams was a licensed funeral director in charge of Williams Funeral Home, Plant City, Florida, between October 1979 and March 1980. Williams was never the licensed funeral director in charge of the Respondent funeral establishment. On or about October 28, 1976, the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers was advised that Respondent F.B. Stone had replaced William Gordon as the funeral director in charge of the Respondent funeral establishment. The Respondent Anderson replaced Respondent F.B. Stone as the funeral director in charge of Respondent establishment on August 4, 1980, and prior to that time, Respondent Anderson was the funeral director in charge of a Lakes Wales funeral home. The Respondent Anderson notified the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers that he was no longer the funeral director in charge of Respondent funeral establishment as of August 27, 1980. It was not until on or about October 1, 1980, that the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers was advised that Respondent Evans was the funeral director in charge of Respondent funeral establishment. By letter dated May 14, 1981, Respondent Larkins notified the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers that he was the funeral director in charge of Respondent funeral establishment as of April 1, 1981. As a normal course of conduct, affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled by the Respondent funeral establishment were filed with the local registrar of vital statistics, more than five working days after the end of each month The following chart sets forth the months in question and the actual date of filing of the affidavits with the local registrar of vital statistics: MONTH ACTUAL DATE OF FILING AFFIDAVIT January 1980 February 28, 1980 February 1980 April 7, 1980 March 1980 October 14, 1980 April 1980 October 14, 1980 May 1980 October 14, 1980 June 1980 October 14, 1980 July 1980 October 14, 1980 August 1980 October 14, 1980 September 1980 (Signed October 7, 1980) October 1980 (Received by Board December 1, 1980) November 1980 (Signed December 9, 1980) December 1980 January 29, 1981 January 1981 February 5, 1981 February 1981 March 18, 1981 March 1981 June 26, 1981 April 1981 June 26, 1981 May 1981 June 26, 1981 June 1981 July 9, 1981 July 1981 (Signed August 5, 1981) August 1981 November 4, 1981 September 1981 November 4, 1981 October 1981 January 3, 1982 November 1981 January 3, 1982 December 1981 January 3, 1982 January 1982 February 14, 1982 February 1982 April 9, 1982 March 1982 April 9, 1982 April 1982 May 6, 1982 May 1982 June 4, 1982 June 1982 July 12, 1982 (Petitioner's Exhibit 1) The Respondents were placed on notice, both written and oral, of the lateness of filing the affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled. A review of Petitioner's Exhibit 1, the affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled, reflects that between July 1979 and September 1979, the affidavits were signed by Elliot C. Bruton as the funeral director in charge when the evidence demonstrates that Respondent F.B. Stone was the licensed funeral director in charge. Between October 1979, and March 1980, James Williams signed the affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled as the funeral director in charge when the evidence demonstrates that Respondent F.B. Stone was the licensed funeral director in charge and Williams was the licensed funeral director in charge of another establishment. Between the dates of April 1980, and July 1980, Respondent Anderson signed the affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled as the funeral director in charge when the evidence demonstrates that Respondent F.B. Stone was the funeral director in charge and Respondent Anderson was employed as the funeral director in charge during this same time period at a Lake Wales funeral home. Respondent Anderson informed an investigator for the Department of Professional Regulation that affidavits for the months of April through July were signed by him and submitted based upon the request of a previous Executive Director of the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers. However, Respondent Anderson also informed the investigator that after submitting the affidavits he remembered that the affidavits were incorrect in certain material respects as to the embalmer, but Respondent Anderson has never attempted to amend the affidavits. While the affidavit for September 1980, lists E. Marion Evans as the embalmer and the funeral director in charge, by letter dated October 7, 1980, the Respondent Evans informed the Board that he was the funeral director in charge as of October 1, 1980. On or about November 1981, the Respondent funeral establishment amended its exterior sign to delete the name of Respondent F.B. Stone as the funeral director in charge and display instead the name of the actual full-time funeral director in charge, at that time, Respondent Larkins. In late March 1981, Dessie Alexander's son, Alfred Alexander, died and Mrs. Alexander made arrangements through Respondent funeral establishment to have her son buried. She called the Respondent funeral establishment and left word for Raymond Gordon to call her back. Raymond Gordon then called her and she told him she wanted to release her son's body to him. Raymond Gordon then came to Dessie Alexander's home and asked her to sign a release paper so that he could pick up the body at the morgue, which she signed. Raymond Gordon called her later and asked her to come to the Respondent funeral establishment to make funeral arrangements. She and her family arrived at the Respondent funeral establishment and, with the assistance of Raymond Gordon, chose a funeral casket. Raymond Gordon took the family to the cemetery to purchase a cemetery lot for the burial. At the Respondent funeral establishment, Raymond Gordon assisted the family in determining the exact funeral arrangements necessary. Marion Evans, although present at the funeral establishment building at certain times, was not involved in the formulation of the funeral arrangements and did not act in a supervisory capacity over Raymond Gordon. Raymond Gordon wrote the funeral purchase contract, and after determining and itemizing the charges, had the family sign the contract. At the funeral service of Alfred Alexander at a local church, Raymond Gordon and Rosalyn Gordon were present, with Ms. Gordon making the payments to the pianist and minister while Raymond Gordon coordinated the funeral services. Respondent Evans was not involved in conducting the funeral service of Alfred Alexander. During this time period, Respondent Evans was the funeral director in charge of the Respondent funeral establishment. Thelma Collins utilized the Respondent funeral establishment on April 29, 1981, when her son, Anthony Bethea, died. Ms. Collins spoke with Raymond Gordon and then he, Stanley Larkins and another unidentified person came to her home. Raymond Gordon spoke with Ms. Collins at her home. At this time, Ms. Collins and Raymond Gordon discussed picking up the body, the time of death and other information concerning the deceased. Ms. Collins' funeral purchase agreement, Petitioner's Exhibit 4, was executed at the Respondent funeral establishment and was drafted, discussed and explained by Raymond Gordon to Ms. Collins when no other employees or agent of the Respondent funeral establishment was present. The funeral service was conducted at a local church and Raymond Gordon, Rosalyn Gordon and an unlicensed workman for the Respondent funeral establishment attended. Ms. Collins does not remember the presence of Respondent Larkins at the funeral service. Marie Butler's sister, Cora Evans, died in January 1980, and the Respondent funeral establishment handled the funeral arrangements and services. Raymond Gordon arranged the funeral service, determined prices and contractual terms and conditions, assisted in determining the arrangements to be made for the funeral service, and conducted and directed the funeral services at the church and grave site. In June 1980, when Respondent Larkins was the registered funeral director in charge of the Respondent funeral establishment, Marie Butler's brother died. Raymond Gordon again personally handled all the funeral arrangements and services by arranging the funeral service, determining prices and contractual terms and conditions, assisting in determining the arrangements to be made for the funeral service, and conducting and directing the funeral services. Respondent Larkins was physically present during most of these activities but did not directly supervise the arrangements of the funeral services. Virgilio O'Farrell died on May 11, 1981, during the time that Respondent Larkins was the funeral director in charge of Respondent funeral establishment. Gail Blackman arranged the funeral services for Mr. O'Farrell through Respondent funeral establishment. Ms. Blackman did not recall dealing with Respondent Larkins in arranging the funeral services through Respondent funeral establishment, but dealt instead with two unknown men from the Respondent funeral establishment. Respondent Larkins testified that during his employ at Respondent funeral establishment, April 1980 through the present, he has been the only licensed funeral director representing the Respondent funeral establishment. Respondent Larkins remembered the Thelma Collins' transaction. On this occasion as well as others, Raymond Gordon was present but Larkins did most of the talking regarding the funeral arrangements. He remembered this particular case because it was the first funeral arrangement he handled in Progress Village. The affidavits of cases embalmed and bodies handled were late in being properly filed due to the fact that Raymond Gordon was acting as the courier of the affidavits and he failed to timely post the same.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED: That a Final Order be entered placing the Respondents Larkins, Evans, Anderson, Stone and Stone Funeral Home on reporting probation for a period of two years and imposing an administrative fine of $750 per Respondent. During the probationary period, the Respondents should be required to regularly certify to the Board that they are complying with all requirements of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes in a timely and accurate manner. DONE and ORDERED this 8th day of November, 1982, in Tallahassee, Florida. SHARYN L. SMITH Hearing Officer Department of Administration Division of Administrative Hearings Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 8th day of November, 1981.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is RECOMMENDED that (1) Respondent Randell E. Aultman be found guilty of violating Sections 470.036(1)(e) and (o) on three occasions by reason of his failure to timely file death certificates and that Aultman be found guilty of violating the same statutes for failure on three occasions to timely obtain a burial-transit permit and to see that such permits accompanied the bodies when being transported out-of-state, and (2) Respondent The American Funeral Home be found guilty of violating Subsections 470.036(1)(e) and (o) on four occasions by reason of its failure to timely file death certificates, and that American be found guilty of violating the same statutes for failure to timely obtain burial- transit permits on five occasions and to see that such permits accompanied the bodies when being transported out-of-state. It is further RECOMMENDED that Respondent Aultman be given a public reprimand and that Respondent The American Funeral Home be given a public reprimand and required to make six monthly filings as set forth in the Conclusions of Law portion of this order. DONE and ENTERED this 5th day of April, 1982, in Tallahassee, Florida. DONALD R. ALEXANDER Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 5th day of April, 1982.
The Issue Whether Respondent's personal and operating licenses should be suspended, revoked, or withdrawn.
Findings Of Fact The State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers charged Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, as follows: The Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, violated Section 470.30(4), Florida Statutes, and Rule 21J7-08 of the Rules of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Emba1mers for Florida in that he permitted Evergreen Mortuary to be operated without the full charge, control and supervision of an individually licensed funeral director and licensed embalmer, and in that he suffered Evergreen Mortuary to pretend or represent that it was legally qualified to perform funeral directing or embaliningby ban improper use of his license, to wit by representing himself to be the regularly employed licensed funeral director and embalmer in charge of such establishment when he was not so employed but rather employed full time as a social worker in Miami, Dade County, Florida; The Respondent , Elmer E. Hewitt, violated Section 470.12(1)(k), Florida Statutes, in that as a licensed embalmer he violated the provisions of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, and in particular, Section 470.30(4). The Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, violated Section 470.l2(2)(p), Florida Statutes, in that as a license funeral director he violated provisions of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, and in particular Section 470.30(4). The Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, is listed in the records of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers of Florida as a licensed funeral director and embalmer regularly employed in charge of Evergreen Mortuary located at 325 Julia Street, Key West, Florida. Mr. Hewitt executed an affidavit on a formal application supplied by the Board stating that he was a licensed funeral director and embalmer regularly employed and in charge of the Evergreen Mortuary. Respondent also executed an affidavit in which it appears that he is a funeral director of Evergreen Mortuary and the only one licensed embalmer and funeral director employed by that establishment on a regular and full time basis. Mr. Hewitt is employed as a Social Worker I for the Comprehensive Alcohol Program, 1400 Northwest Tenth Avenue, Miami, Florida, and maintains a residence in Miami, Florida. The Board contends: (a) That the establishment operating license and the accompanying affidavits executed by Elmer E. Hewitt were false in that Mr. Hewitt was not and is not the licensed funeral director regularly employed in charge of Evergreen Mortuary and that he is not employed by Evergreen Mortuary on a regular and full time basis at his location in Key West, Florida, but rather is employed full time in Miami, Florida; That Mr. Hewitt acted as agent for or in behalf of or in furtherance of the interests of the Respondent Evergreen Mortuary in obtaining an establishment operating license; That he suffered the owners of Evergreen Mortuary to pretend or represent that it was legally qualified to perform funeral directing or embalming by improper use of his license; That Mr. Hewitt was not employed and in charge of Evergreen Mortuary within the meaning of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, and the Rules of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers of Florida; That Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, violated Sections 470.30(4), 470.12(1)(k), and 470.12(2)(p), Florida Statutes; That Respondent, Evergreen Mortuary, violated Section 470.12(4)(a), Florida Statutes, in that Elmer E. Hewitt, a person connected with Evergreen Mortuary as am employed agent, committed violations while acting as agent for or in behalf of or in furtherance of interests of Evergreen Mortuary. Respondent, Elmer E. Hewitt, contends: That he in fact has a residence in Key West, Florida; That he devotes his full time as funeral director and emba1mer to the business of Evergreen Mortuary; That although he is employed on a full time basis at the Comprehensive Alcohol Program, he fulfills his obligations to that job at night and on weekends and other times when he is not performing his duties as a full time employee of Evergreen Mortuary. The Hearing Officer further finds: That under the terms of Respondent Hewitt's employment for the Comprehensive Alcohol Program in Miami, Florida, he is required to work a 40-hour week, but there was no evidence submitted to show' that Respondent Hewitt does in fact work a 40- hour week in his employment in Miami, Florida; The evidence shows and it is found that Elmer E. Hewitt is a full time funeral director and embalmer within the requirements of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, and the Rules of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers of Florida; That Respondent Hewitt is employed by Evergreen Mortuary on a regular basis as required by the statutes and the Rules of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers; That air transportation and telephone service from Miami to Key West provide current information and valid transportation so that the business of Evergreen Mortuary can be conveniently performed even though Respondent Hewitt may be in Miami, Florida.
Recommendation Dismiss the proceedings for the suspension of Elmer E. Hewitt, licensed funeral director and embalmer and dismiss the petition for revocation of the operating license of Evergreen Mortuary. DONE and ORDERED this 12th day of March, 1976. DELPHENE C. STRICKLAND Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 530, Carlton Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304 (904) 488-9675 COPIES FURNISHED: Kenneth Norrie, Esquire Counsel for Petitioner Robert I. Spiegelman, Esquire Counsel for Respondent =================================================================
The Issue The issue in this case is whether Respondent Gary J. Faircloth violated Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, as alleged in the Administrative Complaint.
Findings Of Fact At all times pertinent to this proceeding, Gary J. Faircloth has been licensed as a funeral director and embalmer by the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers, holding license numbers FE 1309, E 1309 and FD 1140. Respondent Faircloth was the funeral director in charge of Community Funeral Home from December 1, 1981 to the present, pursuant to Section 470.024, Florida Statutes. At all times pertinent to this proceeding, Community Funeral Home has been licensed as a funeral establishment by the Board with George Evans, Jr., as the owner of the establishment. Evans is not and has never been licensed as a funeral director, funeral director intern, embalmer or embalmer intern by the Board. During the period that Respondent Faircloth was funeral director in charge of said establishment, Respondent has been the only funeral director and embalmer employed by the establishment. (TR 45-47, 63.) Respondent Faircloth was the funeral director and embalmer responsible for the final disposition of Debra Jean Purter, to include preparation of the required forms. Ms. Purter died in an auto accident in Perry, Florida, on January 21, 1982. Her case was referred to the medical examiner in Tallahassee, Florida. The medical examiner did not complete the medical certificate until February 2, 1982. Respondent Faircloth applied for the burial-transit permit on January 24, 1982, from George Evans, Subregistrar. Evans issued the permit on that date and also granted a five-day extension to file the death certificate. The burial-transit permit was requested timely, and the latest date for filing the death certificate was January 29, 1982. On January 26, 1982, Respondent Faircloth contacted the medical examiner and was advised that the medical examiner would complete the medical certificate. See Petitioner's Exhibit 1, Application for Burial-Transit Permit, Block 5c. The death certificate was filed with the registrar on February 10, 1982. Respondent Faircloth was the funeral director and embalmer responsible for the final disposition of O'Neatha Thomas, to include preparation of the required forms. O'Neatha Thomas died on January 17, 1982, in Perry, Florida. Her case was referred to the medical examiner in Tallahassee, Florida. A burial-transit permit was issued by George Evans, Subregistrar. From the copies, it cannot be determined when Respondent Faircloth requested the burial-transit permit from Evans. A five-day extension to file the death certificate was granted by Evans. The latest date for filing the death certificate would have been January 25, 1982. On January 22, 1982, Respondent Faircloth contacted the medical examiner and was advised by Mrs. Silver of Ketchum, Wood or Burgert that the medical certificate would be completed and mailed. See Petitioner's Exhibit 2, Application for Burial-Transit Permit, Block 5c. The temporary death certificate was filed with the county on February 15, 1982. The medical certificate was completed on March 10, 1982, and filed with the registrar on that date. George Evans, Subregistrar, was also the owner of Community Funeral Home. As subregistrar, he could issue and received death certificates and burial-transit permits. A subregistrar has ten days to file such documents with the registrar. There is no place on the form to note filing with the subregistrar. Respondent Faircloth was 14 days late filing the death certificate on Ms. Purter. Respondent Faircloth was 29 days late in filing a temporary death certificate on O'Neatha Thomas. Respondent Faircloth admitted that Evans spoke with the family of O'Neatha Thomas to determine what services they desired. Respondent was present and observed the actions of Evans from the adjoining room. Respondent Faircloth further admitted that the memorial and burial services were directed by another funeral director in his behalf.
Recommendation Having found the Respondent, Gary J. Faircloth, guilty of violating Section 470.036(1)(g), Florida Statutes, on two occasions, it is recommended that the Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers fine the Respondent $50 for each violation, or a total of $100. Having found Respondent guilty of violating Section 470.036(1)(a), Florida Statutes, on one occasion, it is recommended that the Board suspend the license of Respondent for a period of one year. DONE and RECOMMENDED this 16th day of December, 1982, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. STEPHEN F. DEAN, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 16th day of December, 1982. COPIES FURNISHED: Joseph W. Lawrence, II, Esquire Department of Professional Regulation 130 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Mr. Gary J. Faircloth 605 North Jefferson Street Perry, Florida 32347 Samuel R. Shorstein, Secretary Department of Professional Regulation 130 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Edward P. O'Dowd, Executive Director Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers 111 Coastline Drive, East Suite 507 Jacksonville, Florida 32202 ================================================================= AGENCY FINAL ORDER =================================================================
The Issue Whether the license of Arnett P. Rogers, Funeral Directors' license number 701 and Embalmers' license number 873 and the license of House of Rogers Funeral Home Establishment Operators' license number 6700 should be revoked, suspended or annulled or whether Arnett P. Roger should be otherwise disciplined.
Findings Of Fact Arnett P. Rogers holds Funeral Directors' license number 701 and Embalmers' license number 873 and is the owner of House of Rogers Funeral Home which was issued Establishment Operating license number 6700. Respondent was charged in a complaint issued by Petitioner with violating Setion 470.12(1)(k); Section 470.12 (2)(c); and section 470.12(2)(p), Florida Statutes, in that as a licensed funeral director and embalmer he was found guilty of, after being charged with, a crime of moral turpitude in this State. More specifically, Respondent was charged with being found guilty of violating Section 409.325, Florida Statutes, which prohibits fraud in the handling of federal food stamps. The Respondent, Arnett P. Rogers, was charged with violating the terms of probation imposed upon him by final order of the State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers dated January 31, 1977, which adopted a recommended order dated December 1, 1976, copies of which are attached hereto and made a part hereof, after being charged and found guilty of a crime of moral turpitude in this state. Petitioner charged the Respondent, House of Rogers Funeral Home, with the violation of Section 470.12(4)(a), Florida Statutes, in that Arnett P. Rogers, the licensed funeral director in charge of and owner and operator of said funeral home committed acts in violation of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, by being found guilty of a crime involving moral turpitude in this state. Respondent, House of Rogers Funeral Home, was charged with having violated the terms of the Order of Probation dated January 31, 1977. Upon examination of the evidence submitted and considering the testimony of a witness produced by the Petitioner, it is found that the Arnett Rogers shown in the information filed and judgment of guilt ordered September 23, 1977, which is attached hereto and made a part hereof, is one and the same person as the Respondent, Arnett P. Rogers. No evidence was offered mitigating the apparent turpitude of the offense for which Respondent Roger was found guilty. The Respondent, Rogers, violated the terms and conditions of the Final Order entered on January 31, 1977, which revoked Respondent's licenses but withheld revocation pending the satisfactory completion of a two year probation period beginning on the date the Order was entered. It is found that the conviction of Respondent by Judgment dated June 27, 1977, and filed by the Clerk of the Circuit Court, Fourth Judicial Circuit of Florida, in and for Duval County, Florida, is a violation of the requirements of Chapter 470, Florida Statutes, and is not a "satisfactory completion of a two year probationary period" required by the foregoing Final Order. The adjudication of guilt of a crime proscribed by Section 409.325, Fraud.-Florida Statutes, is a "crime of moral turpitude" and a violation of Section 470.12(2)(c) Florida Statutes. From the testimony and evidence submitted, it is found that Respondent intended to use food stamps as payment for funeral services to be rendered by him and The House of Rogers when he accepted food stamps in a negotiation for a down payment for a funeral. The proposed orders of the parties have been considered in the rendition of this order and any part thereof not directly treated is found to be without merit.
Recommendation Revoke the licenses of Arnett P. Rogers and the House of Rogers Funeral Home. DONE and ENTERED this 6th day of November, 1978, in Tallahassee, Florida. DELPHENE C. STRICKLAND Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 530, Carlton Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304 (904) 488-9675 COPIES FURNISHED: Dewberry, Esquire 1300 Florida Title Building Jacksonville, Florida 32202 Lacy Mahon, Jr., Esquire 350 East Adams Street Jacksonville, Florida 32202
