The Issue Whether Respondent engaged in sanctionable conduct in violation of Medicaid laws, as alleged in the April 9, 2012, sanction letters the Agency for Health Care Administration (ACHA) sent to Respondent in the above-styled cases, and, if so, what sanction(s) should be imposed.
Findings Of Fact AHCA is the state agency charged with administering and overseeing the Medicaid program in Florida. Housed within AHCA is the Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity (MPI). Among MPI's responsibilities is to conduct audits and investigations to ensure that the state's Medicaid providers are in compliance with programmatic requirements. At all times material to the instant cases, Respondent was enrolled in the Florida Medicaid program under two separate provider numbers (Provider No. 679849796, as a provider of Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Medicaid Waiver services, and Provider No. 142150600, as a provider of assistive care services) and subject to the terms of Medicaid Provider Agreements,3/ which contained the following provisions, among others: (5) Provider Responsibilities: The Medicaid provider shall: * * * (b) Keep, maintain, and make available in a systematic and orderly manner all medical and Medicaid-related records as AHCA requires for a period of at least five (5) years. * * * (d) Send, at the provider's expense, legible copies of all Medicaid-related information to authorized state and federal employees, including their agents. The provider shall give state and federal employees access to all Medicaid patient records and to other information that cannot be separated from Medicaid-related records; and, in connection with Provider No. 679849796, it was also subject to the terms of a Medicaid Waiver Services Agreement with the Florida Agency for Persons with Disabilities (APD),4/ in which it had agreed, among other things, to do the following: To permit persons duly authorized by APD, the Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA), or representatives of either, to monitor, audit, inspect, and investigate any recipient records, payroll and expenditure records, (including electronic storage media), papers, documents, facilities, goods and services of the Provider, which are relevant to this Agreement . . . . * * * Upon demand, and at no additional cost to the APD, AHCA, or their authorized representatives, the Provider will facilitate the duplication and transfer of any records or documents (including electronic storage media), during the required retention period . . . . At all times material to DOAH Case No. 12-1664MPI Respondent, as an enrolled Medicaid provider of Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Medicaid Waiver services, was bound by the following provisions of the Developmental Disabilities Waiver Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook dealing with employee training and recordkeeping requirements, which handbook provisions were incorporated by reference (along with the other provisions of the handbook) in Florida Administrative Code 59G-13.083: Companion Provider Requirements * * * Training Requirements Proof of training in the areas of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR), HIV/AIDS and infection control is required within 30 days of initially providing companion services. Proof of annual or required updated training shall be maintained on file for review. The provider is responsible for all training requirements outlined in the Core Assurances. Note: Refer to the Core Assurances in Appendix A for the provider training requirements. . . . * * * Appendix A: Core Assurances for Providers of Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Waiver Services Program * * * 2.1 Required Training The provider and its employees will ensure they receive the specific training required to successfully serve each recipient including the following topics: * * * H. All direct service providers hired after 90 days from the effective date of this rule are required to complete the Agency for Persons with Disabilities developed Zero Tolerance Training course prior to rendering direct care services (as a pre-service training activity). Said training may only be completed via APD's web-based instruction or classroom-led instruction (using APD's approved classroom curriculum presented either by APD staff or an individual who has been trained and approved by APD to conduct such classroom trainings). In addition, all direct service providers shall be required to complete the APD developed Zero Tolerance training course at least once every three years. The provider shall maintain on file for review, adequate and complete documentation to verify its participation, and the participation of its employees, in the required training sessions. The documentation for the above listed training shall, at a minimum, include the training topic(s), length of training session, date and location of training, name and signature of trainer, name and signature of person(s) in attendance. Proof of training shall be on file and available for monitoring and review. At all times material to DOAH Case No. 12-1841MPI, Respondent, as an enrolled Medicaid provider of assistive care services, was bound by the following provisions of the Assistive Care Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook dealing with health assessments, which handbook provisions were incorporated by reference (along with the other provisions of the handbook) in Florida Administrative Code Rule 59G-4.025: Recipients receiving Assistive Care Services must have a complete assessment at least annually by a physician or other licensed practitioner of the healing arts (Physician Assistant, Advanced Registered Nurse Practitioner, Registered Nurse) or sooner if a significant change in the recipient's condition occurs (see below for a definition of a significant change). An annual assessment must be completed no more than one year plus fifteen days after the last assessment. An assessment triggered by a significant change must be completed no more than fifteen days after the significant change. -The assessment for a resident of a ALF or AFCH must be completed by a physician or other licensed practitioner of the healing arts (Physician Assistant, Advanced Registered Nurse Practitioner, Registered Nurse) acting within the scope of practice under state law, physician assistant or advanced registered practitioner. -The assessment for a resident of a RTF must be completed by a physician or licensed mental health professional. The assessment must document the need for at least two of the four ACS components. The assessment for ALF residents must be recorded on the Resident Health Assessment for Assisted Living Facilities, AHCA Form 1823. At all times material to both DOAH Case No. 12-1664MPI and DOAH Case No. 12-1841MPI, Respondent was also bound by the following provisions of the Florida Medicaid Provider General Handbook, which were incorporated by reference in Florida Administrative Code Rule 59G-5.020 and applied to all enrolled Medicaid providers, including providers of Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Medicaid Waiver services and providers of assistive care services: Record Keeping Requirement Medicaid requires that the provider retain all business records as defined in 59G- 1.010(30) F.A.C., medical-related records as defined in 59G-1.010(154) F.A.C., and medical records as defined in 59G-1.010(160) F.A.C. on all services provided to a Medicaid recipient.[5/] Records can be kept on paper, magnetic material, film, or other media including electronic storage, except as otherwise required by law or Medicaid requirements. In order to qualify as a basis for reimbursement, the records must be signed and dated at the time of service, or otherwise attested to as appropriate to the media. Rubber stamped signatures must be initialed. The records must be accessible, legible and comprehensible. * * * Record Retention Records must be retained for a period of at least five years from the date of service. * * * Right to Review Records Authorized state and federal agencies and their authorized representatives may audit or examine a provider's or facility's records. This examination includes all records that the agency finds necessary to determine whether Medicaid payment amounts were or are due. This requirement applies to the provider's records and records for which the provider is the custodian. The provider must give authorized state and federal agencies and their authorized representatives access to all Medicaid patient records and to other information that cannot be separated from Medicaid- related records. The provider must send, at his expense, legible copies of all Medicaid-related information to the authorized state and federal agencies and their authorized representatives upon request of AHCA. At the time of the request, all records must be provided regardless of the media format on which the original records are retained by the provider. All medical records must be reproduced onto paper copies. * * * Incomplete Records Providers who are not in compliance with the Medicaid documentation and record retention policies described in this chapter may be subject to administrative sanctions and recoupment of Medicaid payments. Medicaid payments for services that lack required documentation or appropriate signatures will be recouped. Note: See Chapter 5 in this handbook for information on administrative sanctions and Medicaid payment recoupment The foregoing contractual and handbook provisions supplemented section 409.913(9), Florida Statutes, which then provided (as it still does) as follows: A Medicaid provider shall retain medical, professional, financial, and business records pertaining to services and goods furnished to a Medicaid recipient and billed to Medicaid for a period of 5 years after the date of furnishing such services or goods. The agency may investigate, review, or analyze such records, which must be made available during normal business hours. However, 24-hour notice must be provided if patient treatment would be disrupted. The provider is responsible for furnishing to the agency, and keeping the agency informed of the location of, the provider's Medicaid- related records. The authority of the agency to obtain Medicaid-related records from a provider is neither curtailed nor limited during a period of litigation between the agency and the provider. On or about December 6, 2011, MPI investigators visited Respondent's facility to review Respondent's Medicaid-related records, but left before completing their review. Approximately a month later, MPI sent Respondent a letter, dated January 5, 2012, concerning claims that Respondent had filed under its Provider No. 679849796 as a provider of Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Medicaid Waiver services (January 5 Letter). The letter read as follows: The Agency for Health Care Administration (Agency), Office of Inspector General, Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity is in the process of completing a review of claims billed to Medicaid during the period June 01, 2011, through December 01, 2011, to determine whether the claims were billed and paid in accordance with Medicaid policy. Pursuant to Section 409.913, Florida Statutes (F.S.), this is official notice that the Agency requests the documentation for services paid by the Florida Medicaid provider to the above provider number [679849796]. The Medicaid-related records to substantiate billing for the [four] recipients identified on the enclosed printout are due within fifteen (15) calendar days of your receipt of this notification. Please submit the documentation and the attached Certification of Completeness of Records to the Agency within this timeframe, or other mutually agreed upon timeframe. Correspondence and requested records should be sent to the following address: Victor Rivera, Investigator Agency for Health Care Administration Medicaid Program Integrity 400 West Robinson Street, Suite S309 South Tower, Hurston Building Orlando, Florida 32801 In accordance with Section 409.913, F.S., and Rule 59G-9.070, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), the Agency shall apply sanctions for violations of federal and state laws, including Medicaid policy. Pursuant to the aforementioned provisions, failure to provide all Medicaid-related records in compliance with this request will result in the application of sanctions, which include, but are not limited to, fines, suspension and termination. The Medicaid-related records associated with this review should be retained until [the review is] completed. If you have any questions, please contact Victor Rivera, Investigator, at (407)420- 2524. The Certification of Completeness of Records form enclosed with the letter was to be completed by the provider's "official custodian of records," and it contained the following verification and certification: I hereby verify that I have searched the Medicaid-related records maintained by the Provider and have determined that the attached records consisting of (# of pages) are true and correct copies of the Medicaid- related records requested by the Agency for Health Care Administration, Office of the Inspector General, Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity. I further certify that these are all of the Medicaid-related records that were made at or near the time that the services were rendered by, or from information transmitted by, the Provider; are kept in the course of the regularly conducted business of the Provider; and that it is the regular practice of the Provider to keep such records. Also accompanying the letter was a printout providing information concerning "documentation organization." Among other things, it advised that the "employee documentation" that needed to be submitted included "[c]opies of all required AHCA training certificates," and it contained the further advisement that "[f]ailure to follow the aforementioned guidelines and/or failure to provide the [sic] ALL of the requested documentation for ALL staff members who provided services to Medicaid Recipients during the predetermined audit period w[ould] result in the [a]application of sanctions," including "fines." The January 5 Letter and accompanying documents were received by Respondent on January 9, 2012. Ten days later, MPI sent Respondent a second letter, dated January 19, 2012 (January 19 Letter). This letter concerned claims that Respondent had filed under its Provider No. 142150600 as a provider of assistive care services, and it provided as follows: The Agency for Health Care Administration (Agency), Office of Inspector General, Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity is in the process of completing a review of claims billed to Medicaid during the period January 1, 2011, through November 30, 2011, to determine whether the claims were billed and paid in accordance with Medicaid policy. Pursuant to Section 409.913, Florida Statutes (F.S.), this is official notice that the Agency requests the documentation for services paid by the Florida Medicaid provider to the above provider number [143150600]. The Medicaid-related records to substantiate billing for the [four] recipients identified on the enclosed printout are due within fifteen (15) calendar days of your receipt of this notification. Please submit copies of the Medicaid-related records and the attached Certification of Completeness of Records to the Agency within this timeframe, or other mutually agreed upon timeframe. Correspondence and requested records should be sent to the following address: Victor Rivera, Investigator Agency for Health Care Administration Medicaid Program Integrity 400 West Robinson Street, Suite 309 South Tower, Hurston Building Orlando, Florida 32801 In accordance with Section 409.913, F.S., and Rule 59G-9.070, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), the Agency shall apply sanctions for violations of federal and state laws, including Medicaid policy. Pursuant to the aforementioned provisions, failure to provide all Medicaid-related records in compliance with this request will result in the application of sanctions, which include, but are not limited to, fines, suspension and termination. The Medicaid-related records associated with this review should be retained until [the review is] completed. If you have any questions, please contact Victor Rivera, Investigator, at (407)420- 2524. At the bottom of the "enclosed printout" referenced in the letter was the following cautionary advisement: Please refer to your Assistive Care Services handbook, July 2009, for information on the required documentation for recipient files. The Certification of Completeness of Records form enclosed with the letter was identical to the Certification of Completeness of Records form that had accompanied the January 5 Letter. The January 19 Letter and accompanying documents were received by Respondent on January 21, 2012. Respondent, through its owner/administrator Angel Cox, responded to the records requests made in the January 5 and January 19 Letters by providing MPI with copies of numerous documents, along with two completed, signed, and dated Certifications of Completeness of Records (one for each records request), on January 24, 2012.6/ Ms. Cox supplemented this response by faxing additional copies to MPI on February 7, 2012. Victor Rivera, the MPI investigator to whom Respondent had been directed to send its responses to MPI's January 5, 2012, and January 19, 2012, records requests, reviewed the documentation that Ms. Cox had submitted and determined that the following Medicaid-related records that Respondent had been requested to produce in the January 5 and January 19 Letters were missing (hereinafter referred to collectively as the "Further Required Documentation"): written proof that D. S., an employee of Respondent's who had helped deliver services for which Respondent had billed the Florida Medicaid program from June 1, 2011, through December 1, 2011, under its Developmental Disabilities Home and Community-Based Medicaid Waiver services provider number, had completed the infection control and zero tolerance training required by the Developmental Disabilities Waiver Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook; and the annual health assessments required by the Assistive Care Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook for the four recipients of the services for which Respondent had billed the Florida Medicaid program from January 1, 2011, through November 30, 2011, under its assistive care services provider number. At all times material to the instant cases, Respondent had the Further Required Documentation in its possession,7/ however, Ms. Cox had inadvertently failed to include these documents in the submissions she made (on behalf of Respondent) in response to MPI's January 5 and January 19 Letters. Ms. Cox first learned that the Further Required Documentation was missing during a telephone conversation she had with Mr. Rivera at the end of March 2012, when he advised her of the omission and told her that she needed to get these documents to him "as soon as possible."8/ On April 1 or 2, 2012, no more than three or four days after this telephone conversation, Ms. Cox provided Mr. Rivera, by fax, with copies of the following: a certificate of completion issued by APD to employee D. S. on April 28, 2010, for "Zero Tolerance Training"; a certificate of completion issued by All Metro Health Care to employee D. S. for "Infection Control Guidelines" training completed on February 12, 2011; and a completed March 2011 annual health assessment recorded on AHCA Form 1823 (2011 Health Assessment Form) for each of the four recipients identified in the printout accompanying the January 19 Letter. Respondent also had in its possession the previous year's completed AHCA Form 1823 (2010 Health Assessment Form) for each of these recipients, but Ms. Cox did not fax copies of these forms9/ to Mr. Rivera because she reasonably believed that Mr. Rivera had asked only for the 2011 Health Assessment Forms.10/ MPI tries to "work with the [Medicaid] providers." If a provider is asked by MPI to provide, "as soon as possible," a specified document or documents previously requested but not produced and the provider, in response to such a follow-up request, produces the document(s) in question within a matter of days, it is MPI's practice to not impose any sanctions on the provider and, instead, to "move on to the next case."11/ In the instant cases, however, in an unexplained departure from that practice, MPI chose to issue the April 9, 2012, sanction letters set out above. It is these sanction letters that frame the issues to be resolved in these cases.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is hereby RECOMMENDED that the Agency for Health Care Administration dismiss the allegations made against Respondent in the April 9, 2012, sanction letters issued in these cases and it not impose any sanctions against Respondent for the conduct alleged in these letters. DONE AND ENTERED this 21st day of February, 2013, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S STUART M. LERNER Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 21st day of February, 2013.
Conclusions THE PARTIES resolved all disputed issues and executed a Settlement Agreement. The parties are directed to comply with the terms of the attached settlement agreement. Based on the foregoing. this file is CLOSED. DONE and ORDERED on this the DR say of Mila. 2014, in Tallahassee, Florida. ZABETH DUDEK, fee — Agency for Health Care Administration Agency For Healthcare Administration V. Gary Marder D.O. C.1. No. 12-2625-000 Filed October 14, 2014 2:14 PM Division of Administrative Hearings A PARTY WHO IS ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY THIS FINAL ORDER IS ENTITLED TO A JUDICIAL REVIEW WHICH SHALL BE INSTITUTED BY FILING ONE COPY OF A NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH THE AGENCY CLERK OF AHCA, AND A SECOND COPY ALONG WITH FILING FEE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW, WITH THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL IN THE APPELLATE DISTRICT WHERE THE AGENCY MAINTAINS ITS HEADQUARTERS OR WHERE A PARTY RESIDES. REVIEW PROCEEDINGS SHALL BE CONDUCTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FLORIDA APPELLATE RULES. THE NOTICE OF APPEAL MUST BE FILED WITHIN 30 DAYS OF RENDITION OF THE ORDER TO BE REVIEWED. Copies furnished to: Robert Antonie Milne. Esq., Assistant Attorney General Florida Bar No.: 622338 Office of the Attorney General The Capitol, Suite PL-01 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1050 Telephone: (850) 414-3713 Facsimile: (850) 922-6425 Robert.Milne@myfloridalegal.com Julie Gallagher, Esq., Julie. gallagher@akerman.com Akerman Senterfitt Suite 1200 106 Kast College Avenue Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Kelly Bennett, Chief Medicaid Program Integrity Finance and Accounting Health Quality Assurance Florida Department of Health Agency For Healthcare Administration V. Gary Marder 0.0. C.l, No. 12-2625-000 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE THEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished to the above named addressees by U.S. Mail or other designated method on this the 7 A ot © S24. J Shoop, Esquire Agency Clerk State of Florida Agency tor Health Care Administration 2727 Mahan Drive, MS #3 Tallahassee, Florida 32308-5403 (850) 412-3630/FAX (850) 921-0158 Agency For Healthcare Administration V. Gary Marder D.O. C.I. No. 12-2625-000 STATE OF FLORIDA AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION STATE OF FLORIDA, AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION, Petitioner, DOAH CASE NO: 14-2456MPI PROVIDER NO.: 000455900 VS. CAL NO,: £2-2625-000 NPUNO.: 1730117003 LICENSE NO: 084773 GARY L. MARDER, D.O, Respondent, / SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Petitioner, the STATE OF FLORIDA, AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION, (“AHCA” or “Agency”), and Respondent, GARY L. MARDER, D.O. (SPROVIDER”), by and through the undersigned, hereby stipulate and agree as follows: 1, The parties enter into this agreement for the purpose of memorializing the resolution of this matter. 2. PROVIDER is a Medicaid provider in the State of Florida, provider number 000455900, and was a provider during the audit period. 3. In its Final Audit Report, dated October 7, 2013, the Agency notified PROVIDER. that a review of Medicaid claims performed by the Agency’s Office of (he Inspector General, Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity (“MPI”), during the period of December 1, 2008, through May 31, 2011, indicated that certain claims, in whole or in part, were inappropriately paid by Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, 0.0. C.L. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page lofé Medicaid. The Agency sought repayment of this overpayment, in the amount of one hundred and fifty-four thousand five hundred and sixty-four dollars and six cents ($154,564.06). Additionally, the Agency applied sanctions in accordance with Sections 409,913(15), (16), and (17), Florida Statutes, and Rule 59G-9.070(7), Florida Administrative Code. Specifically, the Agency assessed the following sanctions against PROVIDER: a fine in the amount of thirty thousand nine hundred and twelve dollars and eighty-one cents ($30,912.81) for violation(s) of Rule 59G-9.070(7)(e), Florida Administrative Code; and costs in the amount of three thousand, five hundred and fifty-five dollars and twenty cents ($3,551.20). The iotal amount due was one hundred and cighty-nine thousand, twenty-eight dollars and seven cents ($189,028.07). 4, In response to the audit report dated October 7, 2013, PROVIDER filed a Petition for Formal Administrative Hearing. 5. Subsequent to issuance of the FAR, the PROVIDER submitted additional documentation and clarifications to AHCA regarding the alleged overpayment and sanctions amount. Based on further review AHCA has revised the final overpayment to one hundred forty five thousand, four hundred dollars and twenty-five cents ($145,400.25). The Agency also imposed a sanction in the amount of six thousand dollars ($6,000.00) and assessed cost in the amount of three thousand, seven hundred fifty-one dollars and twenty cents ($3,751.20). The total amount due arising from this case is one hundred fifty-five thousand, one hundred fifty-one hundred dollars and forty-five cents ($155,151.45). 6. In order to resolve this matter without further administrative proceedings, PROVIDER and AHCA agree as follows: Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, D.O. C.I. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page 2 of 6 6. 7. a. AHCA agrees to accept the payment set forth hercin in settlement of the after, fines and costs, arising from the above-referenced Audit. b. PROVIDER agrees to pay AHCA the sum of onc hundred fifty-five thousand, one hundred fifty-one dollars and forty-five cents ($155,151.45), The outstanding balance accrues at 10% interest per year. Within thirty (30) days of entry of the Final Order but by no later than December 10, 2014, whichever date is the last to occur, PROVIDER will make one payment of one hundred fifty-five thousand, one hundred fifty-one dollars and forty-five cents ($155,151.45). ce PROVIDER and AHICA agree that full payment, as set forth above, resolves and settles this case completely and releases both parties from any administrative or civil liabilities arising from the findings relating to the claims determined to have been overpaid as referenced in audit C.1. NO.: 12-2625-000, d. PROVIDER agrees that it shall not re-bill the Medicaid Program in any manner for claims that were not covered by Medicaid, which are the subject of the review in this case. Payment shall be made to: AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION Medicaid Accounts Receivable - MS #14 2727 Mahan Drive, Bldg, 2, Ste-200 Tallahassee, Florida 32308 PROVIDER agrees that failure to pay any monies due and owing under the terms of this Agreement shall constitute PROVIDER’S authorization for the Agency, without further Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, D,O, C.J. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page 3 of 6 notice, to withhold the total remaining amount due under the terms of this agreement from any monies due and owing to PROVIDER for any Medicaid claims. 8. AHCA reserves the right to enforce this Agreement under the laws of the State of Florida, the Rules of the Medicaid Program, and all other applicable rules and regulations. 9. This settlement does not constitute an admission of wrongdoing or error by either party with respect to this case or any other matter. 10, The signatories to this Agreement, acting in a representative capacity, represent that they are duly authorized to enter into this Agreement on behalf of the respective parties. 11, This Agreement shall be construed in accordance with the provisions of the laws of Florida. Venue for any action arising from this Agreement shall be in Leon County, Florida. 12, This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between PROVIDER and AHCA, including anyone acting for, associated with or employed by them, concerning all matters and supersedes any prior discussions, agreements or understandings; there are no promises, representations or agreements between PROVIDER and AHICA other than as sel forth herein, No modification or waiver of any provision shall be valid unless a written amendment to the Agreement is completed and properly executed by the parties. 13. This is an Agreement of Settlement and Compromise, made in recognition that the parties may have different or incorrect understandings, information and contentions as to facts and law, and with each party compromising and settling any potential correctness or incorrectness of its understandings, information and contentions as to facts and law, so that no nusunderstanding or misinformation shall be a ground for rescission hereof. Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, D.O. C.h. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page 4 of § 14, PROVIDER expressly waives in this matter its right to any hearing pursuant to sections 120,569 or 120.57, Florida Statutes, the making of findings of fact and conclusions of law by the Agency, and all further and other proceedings to which it may be entitled by law or rules of the Agency regarding this proceeding and any and all issues raised herein. PROVIDER further agrees that it shall not challenge or contest any Final Order entered in this matter which is consistent with the terms of this settlement agreement in any forum now or in the future available to it, including the right to any administrative proceeding, circuit or federal court action or any appeal. 15. PROVIDER does hereby discharge the State of Florida, Agency for Health Care Administration, and its agents, representatives, and attorneys of and from all claims, demands, actions, causes of action, suits, damages, losses and expenses, of any and every nature whatsoever, arising owl of or in any way related to this matter, AHCA’s actions herein, including, but not limited to, any claims that were or may be asserted in any federal or state court or administrative forum, including any claims arising out of this agreement. 16. The parties agree to bear their own attorney’s fees and, except those cost specified to be paid by the Provider in this settlement agreement if any. 17, This Agreement is and shall be deemed jointly drafted and written by all parties to it and shal] not be construed or interpreted against the party originating or preparing it. 18. To the extent that any provision of this Agreement is prohibited by law for any reason, such provision shall be effective to the extent not so prohibited, and such prohibition shall not affect any other provision of this Agreement. Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, D.O. C.1. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page 5 of 6 49. This Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding on cach party's successors, assigns, heirs, administrators, representatives and trustees. 20. All times stated herein are of the essence of this Agreement, ai. This Agreement shall be in full force and effect upon execution by the respective Dated: Wis, 2014 AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION 2727 Mahan TD rive, Bldg. 3, Mail Stop #3 llahagsee, 1. 2308-5403 Dated: uf; 7. 2014 Dated: 16/ f, » 2014 pated: /C/S?, 2014 Require 3 Counset piss Sec : mu jee —— ome ‘Assistant Attomey General Agency for Health Care Administration v. Gary L. Marder, D.0. C4. No 12-2625-000 Settlement Agreement Page 6 of 6 (Page 1 of 9) FLORIDA AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION, RICK SCOTT ELIZABETH DUDEK GOVERNOR SECRETARY ene CLIZAOC IN UUWER GOVERNOR SECRETARY CERTIFIED MAIL No.: 7009 2820 0001 5675 2068 October 7, 2013 Provider No: 000455900 NPI No: 1730117003 License No.: OS4773 Gary L. Marder 9580 S. US Highway 1 Port St. Lucie, FL. 34952-4217 In Reply Refer to FINAL AUDIT REPORT C.l.: No. 12-2625-000 Dear Provider: The Agency for Health Care Administration (Agency), Office of Inspector General, Bureau of Medicaid Program Integrity, has completed a review of claims for Medicaid reimbursement for dates of service during the period December 1, 2008, through May 31, 2011. A preliminary audit report dated October 15, 2012 was sent to you indicating that we had determined you were overpaid $145,400.25. Based upon a review of all documentation submitted, we have determined that you were overpaid $154,564.06 for services that in whole or in part are not covered by Medicaid. A fine of $30,912.81 has been applied. The cost assessed for this audit is $3,551.20. The total amount due is $189,028.07. Be advised of the following: (1) In accordance with Sections 409.913(15), (16), and (17), Florida Statutes (F.S.), and Rule . $9G-9.070, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), the Agency shall apply sanctions for violations of federal and state laws, including Medicaid policy. This letter shall serve as notice of the following sanction(s): e A fine of $30,912.81 for violation(s) of Rule Section 59G-9.070(7) (e), F.A.C. (2) Pursuant to Section 409.913(23) (a), F.S., the Agency is entitled to recover all investigative, legal, and expert witness costs. . This review and the determination of overpayment were made in accordance with the provisions of Section 409.913, F.S. In determining the appropriateness of Medicaid payment pursuant to Medicaid policy, the Medicaid program utilizes procedure codes, descriptions, policies, limitations and requirements found in the Medicaid provider handbooks and Section 409.913, F.S. In applying for Visit AHCA online at 2727 Mahan Drive, MS# 6 hitp://ahca.myflorida.com Tallahassee, Florida 32308 Te meaner ne CR Re ARO IR RR A NR NEAL ET RM I A ce tne A meena A eke tn HH eae a emer eT Se ge (Page 2 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 C.I. No.: 12-2625-000 Page 2 Medicaid reimbursement, providers are required to follow the guidelines set forth in the applicable rules and Medicaid fer, schedules, as, acomuleated jz. the, Madicridnglicxhaedkerks: billinabublstiatoar dbs and Medicaid fee schedules, as promulgated in the Medicaid policy handbooks, billing bulletins, and the Medicaid provider agreement. Medicaid cannot pay for services that do not meet these guidelines. Below is a discussion of the particular guidelines related to the review of your claims, and an explanation of why these claims do not meet Medicaid requirements. The audit work papers are attached, listing the claims that are affected by this determination. REVIEW DETERMINATIONS) 1. Medicaid policy addresses the requirements for enrollment and participation in the Medicaid program. In order to bill for services provided by another practitioner (physician, ARNP, PA), that practitioner must be enrolled in Medicaid, and must also be enrolled as part of a group practice for which you are listed as the pay-to provider. The billing must reflect the Medicaid number of the treating practitioner. You billed and received payment for services performed by another practitioner who was not enrolled in Medicaid and/or not in a group with you at the time the services were rendered. This finding applies to pathology claims. Payment made to you for these services is considered an overpayment. 2. A review of your medical records revealed that some services rendered were erroneously coded on the submitted claim. The appropriate code was applied and the payment adjusted. The difference between the amount paid and the payment for the correct procedure code is considered an overpayment. 3. Medicaid policy requires that services performed be medically necessary for the diagnosis and treatment of an illness. You bitled and received payments for services for which the medical records, when reviewed by a Medicaid physician consultant, indicated that the services provided did not meet the Medicaid criteria for medical necessity. The claims which were considered medically unnecessary were disallowed and the money you were paid for these procedures is considered an overpayment. 4. Medicaid policy defines the varying levels of care and expertise required for the evaluation and management procedure codes for office visits. The documentation you provided supports a lower level of office visit than the one for which you billed and received payment. This determination was made by a peer consultant in accordance with Sections 409.913 and 409.9131, F.S. The difference between the amount you were paid and the correct payment for the appropriate level of service is considered an overpayment. 5. Medicaid policy addresses the type of pathology services covered by Medicaid. You billed and received payment for laboratory tests that were performed outside your facility by an independent laboratory. Payments made to you in these instances are considered overpayments. 6. Medicaid policy specifies how medical records must be maintained. A review of your medical records revealed that some services for which you billed and received payment were not documented. Medicaid requires documentation of the services and considers payments made for services not appropriately documented an overpayment. (Page 3 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 C1. No.: 12-2625-000 Page 3 10. 1 — Tn order ta qualify as a hasis for reimbursement. Medicaid policy requires that records must be In order to qualify as a basis for reimbursement, Medicaid policy requires that records must be signed and dated at the time of service, or otherwise attested to as appropriate to the media. Payments made to you in instances where the records submitted for review were non- contemporaneous, are considered overpayments. Medicaid policy requires a physician’s signature to substantiate the service billed. A review of your medical records revealed that in some instances, a rubber stamp was used in lieu of a physician’s written signature. Rubber stamp signatures must be initialed. The services that you billed and received payment for, in which a rubber stamp was utilized, are considered overpayments. Medicaid policy states that, to receive the physician 100% reimbursement, Advanced Registered Nurse Practitioners and Physician assistants must be supervised by the treating physician. Supervision is shown by the physician’s dated signature on the medical record. You billed Medicaid for services at the 100% reimbursement level when the medical record did not indicate that the service was supervised. Twenty percent of the reimbursement is considered an overpayment. Your records indicate instances of unbundling (using two CPT codes when one of these codes incorporates the elements of the other). The unbundled code has been denied. . As to Recipient #25: Medicaid requires a radiological physicist to be under the direct supervision of a physician (2010 Physician Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook, 2- 115). When Dr. Marder was out of the country he was not on the premises to provide direct supervision for these services. Medicaid requires indirect supervision by a physician for non- invasive radiology and nuclear medicine services (2010 Physician Services Coverage and Limitations Handbook, 2-112). Indirect supervision means that the physician must be reasonably available, so as to be physically present to provide consultation or direction in a timely fashion as required for appropriate care of the recipient. When Dr. Marder was out of the country, he was not available to provide indirect supervision for services. Dr. Marder was also unavailable to prescribe services for this recipient. CPT code 77401 is allowed once per patient per session regardless of the number of treatment areas. CPT code 77427 is billed per 5 treatments (not areas). CPT code 77336 is billed once per week. CPT code 77300 requires a prescription by the physician. Payments made to you for these services are considered an overpayment. OVERPAYMENT CALCULATION A random sample of 35 recipients respecting whom you submitted 388 claims was reviewed. For those claims in the sample, which have dates of service from December 1, 2008, through May 31, 2011, an overpayment of $15,169.48 or $39.09659794 per claim, was found. Since you were paid for a tota! (population) of 10,485 claims for that period, the point estimate of the total overpayment is 10,485 x $39.09659794 = $409,927.83. There is a 50 percent probability that the overpayment to you is that amount or more. (Page 4 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 CE. No.: 12-2625-000 Page 4 We used the following statistical formula for cluster sampling to calculate the amount due the Agency: een NS Ua, —YB,y Where: N N E = point estimate of overpayment = F' b A, by 3,| U F = number of claims in the population = > B, isl 4, = total overpayment in sample cluster 8B, = number of claims in sample cluster U = number of clusters in the population N = number of clusters in the random sample N N Y = mean overpayment per claim= 5° A, / >)" B, eal get t = ¢ value from the Distribution of f Table All of the claims relating to a recipient represent a cluster. The values of overpayment and number of claims for each recipient in the sample are shown on the attachment entitled “Overpayment Calculation Using Cluster Sampling.” From this statistical formula, which is generally accepted for this purpose, we have calculated that the overpayment to you is $154,564.06 with a ninety-five percent (95%) probability that it is that amount or more. If you are currently involved in a bankruptcy, you should notify your attorney immediately and provide a copy of this letter for them. Please advise your attorney that we need the following information immediately: (1) the date of filing of the bankruptcy petition; (2) the case number; (3) the court name and the division in which the petition was filed (e.g., Northern District of Florida, Tallahassee Division); and, (4) the name, address, and telephone number of your attorney. One mere A Ce en IS RE RU NER REMY HOOT IE BAS gR on ACF nee NTR ee ae (Page 5 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 C.L.No.: 12-2625-000 Page 5 If you are not in bankruptcy and you concur with our findings, remit by certified check in the amount of $189,028.07, which includes the overpayment amount as well as any fines imposed and assessed costs. The check must be payable to the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration. Questions regarding procedures for submitting payment should be directed to Medicaid Accounts Receivable, (850) 412-3901. To ensure proper credit, be certain you legibly record on your check your Medicaid provider number and the C.I. number listed on the first page of this audit report. Please mail payment to: Medicaid Accounts Receivable - MS # 14 Agency for Health Care Administration 2727 Mahan Drive Bldg. 2, Ste. 200 Tallahassee, FL 32308 Pursuant to section 409.913(25)(d), F.S., the Agency may collect money owed by all means allowable by law, including, but not limited to, exercising the option to collect money from Medicare that is payable to the provider. Pursuant to section 409.913(27), F.S., if within 30 days following this notice you have not either repaid the alleged overpayment amount or entered into a satisfactory repayment agreement with the Agency, your Medicaid reimbursements wil! be withheld; they will continue to be withheld, even during the pendency of an administrative hearing, until such time as the overpayment amount is satisfied. Pursuant to section 409.913(30), F.S., the Agency shall terminate your participation in the Medicaid program if you fail to repay an overpayment or enter into a satisfactory repayment agreement with the Agency, within 35 days after the date of a final order which is no longer subject to further appeal. Pursuant to sections 409.913(15)(q) and 409.913(25)(c), F.S., a provider that does not adhere to the terms of a repayment agreement is subject to termination from the Medicaid program. Finally, failure to comply with all sanctions applied or due dates may result in additional sanctions being imposed, You have the right to request a formal or informal hearing pursuant to Section 120.569, F.S. Ifa request for a formal hearing is made, the petition must be made in compliance with Section 28-106.201, F.A.C. and mediation may be available. If a request for an informal hearing is made, the petition must be made in compliance with rule Section 28-106.301, F.A.C. Additionally, you are hereby informed that ifa request for a hearing is made, the petition must be received by the Agency within twenty-one (21) days of receipt of this letter. For more information regarding your hearing and mediation rights, please see the attached Notice of Administrative Hearing and Mediation Rights. rere mE nr he et A NER ET RE EMER NAHE PA Pe ANN (Page 6 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 CI. No.: 12-2625-000 Page 6 Anv onestions von mav have ahout this matter should be directed to: Kris Creel. Investigator. Agency Any questions you may have about this matter should be directed to: Kris Creel, Investigator, Agency for Health Care Administration, Medicaid Program Integrity, 2727 Mahan Drive, Mail Stop #6, Tallahassee, Florida 32308-5403, telephone (850) 412-4600, facsimile (850) 410-1972. AHCA Administrator Office of Inspector General Medicaid Program Integrity RO/KC/te Enclosure(s) Copies furnished to: Julie Gallagher Akerman Senterfitt Suite 1200 106 East College Avenue Tallahassee, FL 32301 Finance & Accounting (Interoffice mail) Health Quality Assurance (E-mail) Department of Health (E-mail) rr are rete seme mann AA A RP RE TE RATA RTA thE TPO RR RR UIA NRE neem A (Page 7 of 9) Gary L. Marder 000455900 CI. No.: 12-2625-000 Page 7 NOTICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING AND MEDIATION RIGHTS UNW 2 Ur ayia pays a es eee ee ee ee You have the right to request an administrative hearing pursuant to Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes. If you disagree with the facts stated in the foregoing Final Audit Report (hereinafter FAR), you may request a formal administrative hearing pursuant to Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes. If you do not dispute the facts stated in the FAR, but believe there are additional reasons to grant the relief you seek, you may request an informal administrative hearing pursuant to Section 120.57(2), Florida Statutes, Additionally, pursuant to Section 120.573, Florida Statutes, mediation may be available if you have chosen a formal administrative hearing, as discussed more fully below. The written request for an administrative hearing must conform to the requirements of either Rule 28- 106.201(2) or Rule 28-106.301(2), Florida Administrative Code, and must be received by the Agency for Health Care Administration, by 5:00 P.M. no later than 21 days after you received the FAR. The address for filing the written request for an administrative hearing is: Richard J, Shoop, Esquire Agency Clerk Agency for Health Care Administration 2727 Mahan Drive, Mail Stop # 3 Tallahassee, Florida 32308 Fax: (850) 921-0158 Phone: (850) 412-3630 The request must be legible, on 8 % by 11-inch white paper, and contain: 1, Your name, address, telephone number, any Agency identifying number on the FAR, if known, and name, address, and telephone number of your representative, if any; 2. Anexplanation of how your substantial interests will be affected by the action described in the FAR; 3. A statement of when and how you received the FAR; 4, Fora request for formal hearing, a statement of all disputed issues of material fact; 5. Fora request for formal hearing, a concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, as well as the rules and statutes which entitle you to relief; 6. For a request for formal hearing, whether you request mediation, if it is available; 7. For a request for informal hearing, what bases support an adjustment to the amount owed to the Agency, and A demand for relief. bad A formal hearing will be held if there are disputed issues of material fact. Additionally, mediation may be available in conjunction with a formal hearing. Mediation is a way to use a neutral third party to assist the parties in a legal or administrative proceeding to reach a settlement of their case. If you and the Agency agree to mediation, it does not mean that you give up the right to a hearing. Rather, you and the Agency will try to settle your case first with mediation. If you request mediation, and the Agency agrees to it, you will be contacted by the Agency to set up a time for the mediation and to enter into a mediation agreement, If a mediation agreement is not reached within 10 days following the request for mediation, the matter will proceed without mediation. The mediation must be concluded within 60 days of having entered into the agreement, unless you and the Agency agree to a different time period. The mediation agreement between you and the Agency will include provisions for selecting ‘the mediator, the allocation of costs and fees associated with the mediation, and the confidentiality of discussions and documents involved in the mediation. Mediators charge hourly fees that must be shared equally by you and the Agency. If a written request for an administrative hearing is not timely received you will have waived your right to have the intended action reviewed pursuant to Chapter 120, Florida Statutes, and the action set forth in the FAR shall be conclusive and final. Fa rn ta eet ER RRS ERR AMI ARERR REE OCR NTRR “ur RSI ye IRAE cen i RRO A en ener reppin cee” (Page 8 of 9) FLORIDA AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION Provider: 000455900 - GARY L MARDER Overpayment Catculation Using Cluster Sampling by Recip Name Dates Of Service: 12/1/2008 through §/31/2011 Dre ek einintn ie meet: - Number of recipients in population: Number of recipients in sample: Total payments in population: No. of claims in population: Recip # ONA OHO DYAA WH = NNN NWUNNN MHA BBB Bo BENBERORBNRSestsZaeR Totals: 35 Using Overpayment per claim method Overpayment per sample claim: Point estimate of the overpayment: Variance of the overpayment: Standard error of the overpayment: Half confidence interval: Overpayment at the 95 % Confidence level: Overpayment run on 10/3/2013 Page 1 of 1 _ Ase, Rannin 1,462 Case ID: 35 $820,719.19 Confidence level: 10,485 {value No. Claims Total Dollars 8 $352.56 3 $138.52 3 $185.90 8 $315.58 6 $730.96 1 $42 18 3 $185.90 5 $203.85 4 $244.06 1 $62.78 7 $398.88 14 $1,817.12 8 $1,272.44 2 $1,122.26 5 $250.73 6 $373.84 9 $954.69 28 $2,703.53 5 $460.73 13 $814.85 3 $119.10 3 $185.90 8 $529 48 4 $26.61 188 $5,610.14 1 $42.18 2 $71 29 4 $338.74 10 $789.00 8 $342.15 2 $97.10 1 $42.18 5 $446.94 10 $513.45 3 $50.16 388 $21,805.75 $39,09659794 $409,927.83 $22,807 ,115,837.63 $151,020.25 $255,363.77 $154,564.06 NPI: 1730117003 49 OROR NNN 12-2625-000 95% 1.690924 Overpayment $86 63 $64.96 $54.96 $89.78 $513.47 $0.00 $135.68 $32.18 $54.96 $0.00 $40.01 $1,489.43 $1,107.15 $1,122.26 $138.09 $121.98 $789.43 $2,306 56 $394.21 $514.63 $62.78 $54.96 $274.80 $0.00 $4,484.14 $0.00 $0.00 $164.88 $560.18 $109.92 $0.00 $0.00 $284.22 $116.75, $10.48 $15,169.48 (Page 9 of 9) If you choose to make payment, please return this page along with your check to: Ae nn ae Maa TIAA Qanen A deniniotratian Agency for Health Care Administration Medicaid Accounts Receivable 2727 Mahan Drive, Mail Stop #14 Tallahassee, Florida 32308 The check must be made payable to: Florida Agency for Health Care Administration Provider Name: Gary L. Marder Provider ID: 000455900 MPI Case #: 12-2625-000 Total Due: $189,028.07 Check Number: # Any questions you may have about this matter should be directed to: Kris Creel, Investigator, telephone (850) 412-4600, facsimile (850) 410-1972. Payment for Medicaid Program Integrity Audit 121 recente (Page 1 of 1) \ i ! ; | j | | | | | | 80 that Wé can retum the card to you. §§ Attach this card to the back of the mallpiece, or on the front if space permits. GARY L. MARDER 9580 S. US HIGHWAY 1 PORT ST LUCIE, FL 34952-4217 C.1 #12-2625-000 KC-re Olan eos wows wel 16.00. 7 Lo! lz Restricted Delivery? (xtra Fea) O ves Mander fomeeyce wee) ____ 700% 2820 OO01 SL?5 20b8 \’ nt a ASO RD TE PS Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt 102895-02.0-1540 UniTED States PosTAL SERVICE Class aoe Postage & Fees Paid ise aoe ¥ ™N 8 oe x FLORIDA AGENCY FOR HOSGEICARE APSO TRATIOON dar o 2727 Mahan Drive, MS #6 @& s Tallahassee, Florida 32308 } Medical Unit Wyapereaf fe Affelpheyhfo dtp fbeeag hy gaffod gag] iD, MPU panty 1D Return Reosist for terchandise
