The Issue Whether Petitioner, a licensed greyhound trainer, committed the offenses alleged in the Amended Administrative Complaint and, if so, the penalties that should be imposed.
Findings Of Fact Petitioner issued Respondent greyhound trainer's license number 156254-1021 on January 10, 2003. Respondent was the trainer of record for the following greyhounds that raced at Hollywood Greyhound Track at the times pertinent to this proceeding: "WP's Dylan," "LM's Ice Age," "Doinwhat Blair," "Okie Leona," "Tom's Rusty," "Hi Accord," "LM's Angel Eyes," and "Miss Challenger." Hollywood Greyhound Track is a facility authorized to conduct pari-mutuel wagering in Florida pursuant to a permit issued by Petitioner. "WP's Dylan" raced in the fourth race at Hollywood Greyhound Track on the afternoon of January 21, 2003. "WP's Dylan" finished fourth in that race. Following the race, urine sample number 908316 was collected from "WP's Dylan" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "LM's Ice Age" raced in the first race at Hollywood Greyhound Track on the evening of January 23, 2003. "LM's Ice Age" finished second in that race. Following the race, urine sample number 907673 was collected from "LM's Ice Age" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "Doinwhat Blair" raced in the third race at Hollywood Greyhound Track on the evening of January 23, 2003. "Doinwhat Blair" finished first in that race. Following the race, urine sample number 908327 was collected from "Doinwhat Blair" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "Okie Leona" raced in the ninth race at Hollywood Greyhound Track on the evening of January 23, 2003. "Okie Leona" finished first in that race. Following the race, urine sample number 908358 was collected from "Okie Leona" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "Tom's Rusty" raced in the fifth race at Hollywood Greyhound Track on the evening of January 25, 2003. "Tom's Rusty" finished first in that race. Following the race, urine sample number 908104 was collected from "Tom's Rusty" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "Hi Accord" raced at Hollywood Greyhound Track on January 25, 2003. Following the race, urine sample number 907704 was collected from "Hi Accord" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "LM's Angel Eyes" raced at Hollywood Greyhound Track on January 25, 2003. Following the race, urine sample number 907694 was collected from "LM's Angel Eyes" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. "Miss Challenger" raced at Hollywood Greyhound Track on January 25, 2003. Following the race, urine sample number 907698 was collected from "WP's Dylan" and was processed at the Racing Laboratory. Petitioner proved that each urine sample involved in this proceeding was collected, maintained, and analyzed pursuant to established, routine procedures. Petitioner established by clear and convincing evidence that all eight urine samples involved in this proceeding tested positive for metabolites of cocaine (benzoylecgonine and/or ecgonine methyl ester). Cocaine is a topical anesthetic, and a Class 1 drug under the Uniform Classification Guidelines for Foreign Substances, as promulgated by the Association of Racing Commissioners, Inc. Cocaine is prohibited in racing animals in Florida. The presence of the metabolites of cocaine in the urine of the eight animals at issue in this proceeding established that the dogs had been administered cocaine prior to the respective races. Respondent testified that he did not administer cocaine to any of the animals involved in this proceeding. Respondent's denial was uncorroborated.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that Petitioner enter a final order revoking Respondent's license and imposing an administrative fine against Respondent in the aggregate amount of $8,000. DONE AND ENTERED this 29th day of May, 2003, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. CLAUDE B. ARRINGTON Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 29th day of May, 2003. COPIES FURNISHED: Joseph M. Helton, Jr., Esquire Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street, Suite 60 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202 Kenneth C. Purdy 15855 Miami Lakeway, North E 248 Hialeah, Florida 33014 David J. Roberts, Director Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0792 Hardy L. Roberts, III, General Counsel Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202
The Issue Whether Rule 61D-6.002(1), Florida Administrative Code, is an invalid exercise of delegated legislative authority.
Findings Of Fact Hennessey is the holder of an unrestricted U-1 Professional Pari-mutuel License authorizing him to train horses, which license is issued to Hennessey by the Department pursuant to the provisions of Section 550.105, Florida Statutes. Hennessey was charged in a hearing before the Stewards at Pompano Park with violating the provisions of Section 550.2415, Florida Statutes, regarding an impermissible drug found in a race horse entered to race by Hennessey. The disciplinary action was initiated by the Stewards against Hennessey after a post-race urine sample taken from a horse trained by Hennessey won a race at Pompano Park indicated the presence of two substances, caffeine and theophylline, a metabolite of caffeine. Hennessey testified at the hearing before the Stewards that he neither administered nor directed anyone to administer caffeine to the subject horse. Application of Rule 61D-6.002, Florida Administrative Code, makes Hennessey strictly liable for impermissible drugs found in horses he enters to race at pari-mutuel wagering facilities in the State of Florida. No evidence of willful administration of caffeine by Hennessey is known to exist. Warren is the holder of an unrestricted U-1 Professional Pari-mutuel License, License Number 0024037-1081, authorizing him to train horses. The license was issued to Warren by the Department pursuant to the provisions of Section 550.105, Florida Statutes. Warren was the trainer of record of a thoroughbred horse named "The Issue is Power," which won the fifth race conducted on November 12, 1999, in Miami, Florida, at the Tropical Park at Calder Race Meeting. After the race concluded, a urine sample, sample number 540322, was taken from "The Issue is Power" at the detention facility operated by the Department. Sample number 540322 was tested by the University of Florida Racing Laboratory, and that sample was found to contain benzoylecgonine, which is a metabolite of cocaine. The estimated concentration of benzoylecgonine was 50 to 54 nanograms per milliliter. Testing of sample number 540322 did not show the presence of egonine methyl ester, which is another metabolite of cocaine. Warren denies that he knowingly or intentionally administered cocaine to the horse "The Issue is Power" at any time. Application of Rule 61D-6.002, Florida Administrative Code, makes Warren strictly liable for impermissible drugs found in horses he enters at pari-mutuel wagering facilities in the State of Florida. No evidence of willful administration of cocaine by Warren is known to exist. Ms. Gangemi, is the holder of an unrestricted U-1 Professional Pari-mutuel License, License Number 0257328-1081, authorizing her to train horses. The license was issued to Ms. Gangemi, by the Department pursuant to the provisions of Section 550.105, Florida Statutes. Ms. Gangemi was the trainer of record of a thoroughbred horse named "Quanchotaug," which finished third in the ninth race race of the matinee performance conducted on July 11, 2000, in Miami, Florida, at Calder Race Course, Inc. After the race concluded a urine sample, sample number 658542, was taken from "Quanchotaug" at the detention facility operated by the Department. Sample number 658542 was tested by the University of Florida Racing Laboratory, and that sample was found to contain benzoylecgonine. The estimated concentration of benzoylecgonine was 10 nanograms per milliliter. A split sample analysis performed by the Center For Tox Services, an independent laboratory in Tempe, Arizona, confirmed the presence of benzoylecgonine in sample number 658542. The estimated concentration of benzoylecgonine was 2 nanograms per milliliter. Application of Rule 61D-6.002, Florida Administrative Code, makes Ms. Gangemi strictly liable for impermissible drugs found in horses she enters to race at pari-mutuel wagering facilities in the State of Florida. No evidence of willful administration of cocaine by Ms. Gangemi is known to exist. Testing of sample 658542 did not show the presence of egonine methyl ester. The administration or exposure of cocaine directly into the post-race urine sample of a horse could result in the presence of the metabolite benzoylecgonine. Pompano Park is authorized to conduct pari-mutuel wagering upon harness horse racing pursuant to a permit issued to it by the Department under Section 550.054, Florida Statutes. Tropical Park is authorized to conduct pari-mutuel wagering upon thoroughbred horse racing pursuant to a permit issued to it by the Department under Section 550.054, Florida Statutes. Calder Race Course is authorized to conduct pari-mutuel wagering upon thoroughbred horse racing pursuant to a permit issued to it by the Department pursuant to Section 550.054, Florida Statutes. Horse racing, at its best, is difficult to control, and would be practically impossible to regulate if every governing rule and regulation were made dependent for validity upon the knowledge or motives of the person charged with a violation. It would be almost impossible to prove guilty knowledge or intent in cases involving a reported positive test for an impermissible substance. Every consideration surrounding the business of operating a race track, and the racing of horses thereon, seems to call for firm and rigid rules placing responsibility and imposing penalties for their violation. The Department currently has six investigators assigned to cover 35 permitholders. The investigators are well known around the various race tracks they cover, which makes catching possible drug violations in the act almost impossible. The Department's investigators are generally notified of a drug confirmation about ten days after a race has been run. Given that there are so few investigators covering 35 tracks and the reports are received ten days after a race, it would be very difficult to successfully determine who administered a prohibited substance to a horse. The trainer is singularly the best individual to hold accountable for the condition of a horse. The trainer is either going to be with the horse at all times or one of his or her employees or contractors is going to be with the horse at all times, whether the horse is racing on an individual day or is merely stabled at the track. A trainer of racing horses is responsible for the animals' athletic conditioning. A trainer is also responsible for providing for the regular care of the horses he trains, including feeding and seeing to the medical needs of the horses. All persons who handle an animal prior to the running of a race are either employees of the track or Department or are employed by or in a professional relationship with the trainer. At no time prior to a race is a trainer or his employer prohibited from seeing to the security of the horse in the paddock. While there are other persons who come in contact with the horse prior to a race, the trainer due to his responsibility for the care and supervision of the animal stands in the best overall position to prevent improper medication of the horse. There is no practical alternative to holding the trainer of record responsible for the condition of the animals he enters to race. The Department's authority to require the return of a purse is insufficient to deter wrongdoers from attempting to affect the outcome of a race. The integrity of the pari-mutuel industry would suffer from the Department's inability to enforce statutes relating to the drugging of racing animals.
The Issue The issue in this case is whether Respondent, Srdan Saric, committed violations of Chapter 550, Florida Statutes (2005), and Florida Administrative Code Chapter 61D-6, as alleged in an Administrative Complaint filed with the Department of Business and Professional Regulation in DBPR Case Nos. 2005042972, 2005039423, and 2005042974, and amended January 30, 2006; and, if so, what disciplinary action should be taken against his State of Florida pari-mutuel wagering occupational license.
Findings Of Fact The Parties. Petitioner, the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Division of Pari-mutuel Wagering (hereinafter referred to as the "Division"), is an agency of the State of Florida created by Section 20.165(2)(f), Florida Statutes, and charged with the responsibility for the regulation of the pari- mutuel wagering industry pursuant to Section 550.0251, Florida Statutes. Respondent, Srdan Saric, is, and was at the times material to this matter, the holder of a pari-mutuel license, number 2016930-1021, issued by the Division. During the time period at issue in this case, Mr. Saric trained harness race horses and was a jockey at the harness race course of Pompano Park Racing (hereinafter referred to as "Pompano Park"), located in Pompano Beach, Florida. Pompano Park is a harness horse racing facility authorized to conduct pari-mutuel wagering in Florida and is the location of all activity material to this matter. On July 27, 2005, Respondent was the trainer of record and jockey for two standard bred harness race horses, known as "Youngbro Clever" and "Swift Courier." Both horses were owned by Jeanette Glowacki. The Events of July 27, 2005. Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier were both scheduled to race at Pompano Park the evening of July 27, 2005. Youngbro Clever was to run in the fourth race and Swift Courier was to run in the twelfth race. The fourth race was scheduled to begin at approximately 8:15 to 8:30 p.m. Both horses were being housed in Barn C of Pompano Park. That barn was shared by the two horses being trained by Mr. Saric and horses owned and trained by Michael Snyder. Tack boxes, where equipment was stored, were located at Barn C adjacent to the wall just outside the horse stalls. Those located in the area where Mr. Saric's horses were housed were considered to be within areas of Barn C which he occupied or had the right to occupy. The tack boxes are part of the premises within the grounds of a racing permitholder where racing animals were lodged or kept and which Mr. Saric occupied or had the right to occupy. At approximately 7:30 p.m., on July 27, 2005, Jeremy Glowacki, the son of the owner of Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier and an employee Mr. Saric had previously fired, informed Pompano Park security supervisor Richard Masters that he had witnessed Mr. Saric place syringes in a tack box located just outside Barn C, Stall 8. Based upon Mr. Glowacki's report, Pompano Park security searched the tack box and found a 35 cc hypodermic syringe with needle attached and a 12 cc hypodermic syringe with needle attached. As a result of the discovery of the syringes, Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier were immediately scratched from their scheduled races and were sent to the State Veterinarian for drug testing. Mr. Saric was also suspended from Pompano Park and remained so at the time of the final hearing of this matter. The State Veterinarian drew blood serum sample 173675 from Youngbro Clever and blood serum sample 173680 from Swift Courier. These samples were processed in accordance with established procedures. Both blood serum samples were, along with the two syringes recovered from Mr. Saric's tack box, sent to the University of Florida Racing Laboratory (hereinafter referred to as the "Racing Laboratory"), for analysis. Results of Racing Laboratory Testing. The Racing Laboratory, following applicable procedures, performed an analysis on the syringes found in Mr. Saric's tack box and the blood serum samples taken from Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier. No prohibited substance was detected by the Racing Laboratory analysis of the 35 cc syringe. Flunixin was detected by the Racing Laboratory analysis of the 12 cc syringe. Flunixin is a "non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug" which can be used to suppress inflammation and provide pain relief to race horses. The Association of Racing Commissioners International, Inc. has classified Flunixin under the Uniform Classification Guidelines for Foreign Substances as a "Class IV" drug. As such, it is considered an "impermissible substance." Flunixin in excess of 200 ng/ml. was also found by the Racing Laboratory in blood serum sample number 173675 which had been collected from Youngbro Clever. Flunixin in excess of 200 ng/ml. was also found by the Racing Laboratory in blood serum sample number 173680, which had been collected from Swift Courier. In addition to Flunixin, the Racing Laboratory test of blood serum sample number 173675 collected from Youngbro Clever and blood serum sample number 173680 collected from Swift Courier also revealed that those samples contained phenylbutazone, or its metabolites, in excess of 16 micrograms per milliliter of serum. Like Flunixin, phenylbutazone is a "non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug" which can be used to suppress inflammation and provide pain relief to race horses. Pursuant to Florida Administrative Code Rule 61D- 6.008, phenylbutazone, unlike Flunixin, may be administered to a race horse in an amount which, following the running of a race, will result in the horse's blood serum being found to contain less than 8 micrograms per milliliter of serum. Dr. Cole testified convincingly and credibly that Flunixin and phenylbutazone had been administered to Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier within 24 hours of their scheduled races on June 27, 2005. Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier, having been administered Flunixin and phenylbutazone within 24 hours of their scheduled races, would have been able to compete at a higher level in their scheduled races than if these drugs had not been ministered to them. According to Dr. Cole, whose unrebutted testimony in this regard is also credited, if Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier had been allowed to run their scheduled races, blood samples collected immediately after their respective races would have revealed the presence of phenylbutazone in each horse in excess of 8 micrograms per milliliter of serum. Mr. Saric's Prior Disciplinary History. Mr. Saric has previously been disciplined by the Division on two separate occasions. On both occasions, Mr. Saric was fined because Methocarbamol (a skeletal muscle relaxant and Class IV drug) was detected in urine samples collected from Youngbro Clever as part of the post race analyses. The first violation for which Mr. Saric was disciplined took place on December 6, 2004. Mr. Saric was fined $250.00 for this violation of Section 550.2415(1)(a), Florida Statutes (2004), and Florida Administrative Code Rule 61D- 6.011(1). The second violation for which Mr. Saric was disciplined took place on April 15, 2005. Mr. Saric was fined $500.00 for this violation of Section 550.2415(1)(a), Florida Statutes, and Florida Administrative Code Rule 61D-6.011(1). Mr. Saric's Responsibility for Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier. While Mr. Saric attempted, unsuccessfully, to prove that he did not place the syringes in his tack box or inject Flunixin and phenylbutazone into Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier, the evidence failed to support such a finding. The evidence also failed to prove that Jeremy Glowacki was responsible for these violations. More importantly, the evidence failed to prove that Mr. Saric took the measures necessary to protect Youngbro Clever and Swift Courier in particular and the racing industry generally from harm, especially considering the fact that this case involves the third time that Youngbro Clever has tested positive for a prohibited substances in his blood.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the final order be entered by the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering, finding that Srdan Saric violated Sections 550.105(5)(b) and 550.2415(1)(c), Florida Statutes, and Florida Administrative Code Rules 61D-6.004(2) and 61D-6.011(1), as described in this Recommended Order; suspending his license for a total period of two years from the date of the final order; and requiring that he pay a fine of $6,000.00. DONE AND ENTERED this 14th day of April, 2006, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S LARRY J. SARTIN Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 14th day of April, 2006. COPIES FURNISHED: S. Thomas Peavey Hoffer Ralf E. Michels Assistants General Counsel Department of Business and Professional Regulation Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering Northwood Centre 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202 Rose H. Robbins, Esquire One Boca Place 2265 Glades Road Suite 324 Atrium Boca Raton, Florida 33431 David J. Roberts, Director Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering Department of Business and Professional Regulation Northwood Centre 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0792 Josefina Tamayo, General Counsel Department of Business and Professional Regulation Northwood Centre 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202
The Issue Whether Respondent is responsible for three violations of Section 550.2415(1)(a), Florida Statutes, as alleged in the Administrative Complaint, and if so, what penalty should be imposed.
Findings Of Fact Petitioner is the State of Florida, Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering which is created by Section 20.165(2)(f), Florida Statutes. The Division regulates pari-mutuel wagering in the State of Florida. Respondent, Donald S. Abbey, was the holder of a pari-mutuel occupational license, License No. 2013666-1081, that was issued by the Division during the month of May 2001. Hialeah Park is a facility operated by a permit holder authorized to conduct thoroughbred racing and pari-mutuel wagering in the State of Florida. Hialeah Park was so authorized in May 2001. On May 16, 2001, Respondent was the trainer of record and owner of a thoroughbred race horse named “Savahanna.” The horse Savahanna finished second in the first race at Hialeah Park on May 16, 2001. Immediately after the race a urine sample was collected from Savahanna. The urine sample was assigned sample No. 748428 and was shipped to the University of Florida Racing Laboratory. The University of Florida Racing Laboratory tested urine sample No. 748428 and found it to contain Terbutaline. On May 16, 2001, Respondent was the trainer of record and owner of a thoroughbred race horse named "Hada Clue." The horse Hada Clue finished second in the third race at Hialeah Park on May 16, 2001. Immediately after the race, a urine sample was collected from Hada Clue. The urine sample was assigned sample No. 748440 and was shipped to the University of Florida Racing Laboratory. The University of Florida Racing Laboratory tested urine sample No. 748440 and found it to contain Terbutaline. On May 18, 2001, Respondent was the trainer of record and owner of a thoroughbred race horse named "Sounds Like Scott." The horse Sounds Like Scott finished second in the fifth race at Hialeah Park on May 16, 2001. Immediately after the race a urine sample was collected from Sounds Like Scott. The urine sample was assigned sample No. 748536 and was shipped to the University of Florida Racing Laboratory. The University of Florida Racing Laboratory tested urine sample No. 748536 and found it to contain Terbutaline. Terbutaline is a bronchodilator and a Class 3 drug according to the Association of Racing Commissioners International classification system. In his Election of Rights, Respondent indicated that he was not the trainer of record. Specifically, he indicated that he had hired a person named Dimitrius Monahas as the trainer with the knowledge of the stewards of Hialeah Park. State Steward Walter Blum testified at the hearing that Respondent was, in fact, the trainer of record for the horses Savahanna, Hada Clue, and Sounds Like Scott. At Hialeah, the trainer of record is determined at the time stall spaces are assigned at the beginning of a meet. Respondent’s name appears in the official programs as both the trainer and the owner of the horses at issue. There is a procedure at Hialeah to notify the stewards of a change in trainer. However, Respondent did not notify the stewards of any change. Dimitrius Monahas signed sample tags for sample Nos. 748440 and 748536 as the owner’s witness. The sample tags list Respondent as both the trainer and owner of the horses.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering enter a final order in this matter suspending Respondent’s occupational license for a period of ten (10) days and imposing a fine of $850.00. It is further recommended that the Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering order that any purse received as a result of the second-place finishes of two of the races in question be returned. DONE AND ENTERED this 16th day of October, 2002, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. DON W. DAVIS Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 16th day of October, 2002. COPIES FURNISHED: Donald S. Abbey Post Office Box 1199 Pilot Point, Texas 76258-1199 Joseph M. Helton, Jr., Esquire Department of Business and Professional Regulation Northwood Centre 1940 North Monroe Street, Suite 60 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202 David J. Roberts, Director Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering Department of Business and Professional Regulation Northwood Centre 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0792 Hardy L. Roberts, III, General Counsel Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2202
